One Gay Couples Battle to Keep Their Twin Sons American

When Andrew and Elad Dvash-Banks won their lawsuit against the State Department in February, they thought that the yearlong legal battle over their Canadian-born sons American citizenship was finally over.

This is over, this is behind us, Andrew Dvash-Banks, a U.S. citizen who was born in California, recalled thinking when U.S. District Judge John F. Walter ruled that the State Departments imposition of a biological requirement for their sons birthright citizenship was based on a strained interpretation of existing immigration law.

But the departments decision earlier this month to appeal the federal judges ruling has drawn national attention to a little-known policy that effectively de-recognizes the marriages of same-sex couples who have children abroadand has once again thrown Andrew, Elad, and their twin sons into legal limbo.


Latest Discounts
  • Get a FREE Sample of This Revolutionary Superfood Today
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Learn Easy Couples Massage Techniques - Full Instructions and Videos
  • Sex games that are used to quickly and easily increase the passion and intimacy of lovemaking.
  • Watch this video and GET READY for the next financial collapse, your family may depend on it.
  • What you absolutely must know about the one you're with. Life changing
  • Bolt your doors... lock your windows... and Watch This Mind-Blowing Video TODAY...
  • Scans your computer for missing, corrupt, or outdated Windows Drivers.
  • Discover The Ultimate Resource For Your Secret Lifestyle Vacation From True Lifestylers.
  • Manual for Handling Twin Screw Boats Simple and Easy to understand
  • Give us 30 minutes and we will give you a sexy body you will love to share
  • Discover The Exact Words To Say That Stop Fights, Arguments and Disagreements.
  • This Affiliate System Will Have You Raking In Massive Commissions From Affiliate Marketing.
  • The Best RSS Autoblog Tool For Blogger Blogspot Blog.
  • The stunning secret of turning your wife on with the push of a button.
  • Reveals 1 Unusual Tip To Eliminate Excessive Sweating Forever In 48 Hours
  • How to Introduce Your Lover To Swinging
  • Discover how to boost your goal achieving skills in 30 days, guaranteed
  • Add More Intimacy, Variety, Pleasure And Fun Into Your Sex Life With This Amazing Foreplay Game.
  • Discover One Weird Trick That Forces Your Body To Eliminate Hemorrhoids In 48 Hours
  • Clickbank Ads
     

    How long are we going to have to live our lives without being 100 percent sure that my government recognizes my family as one unit, and is protecting my son? Andrew asked rhetorically. Its hard enough to raise 2-1/2-year-old twin boys and then to have this additional worry and burden, its just very stressful.

    The policy in question is rooted in the State Departments interpretation of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), a federal law that stipulates that any child born abroad to a married U.S. citizen parent is granted birthright American citizenship. Although the law, which was passed in 1952, makes no reference to biology or assisted reproductive technology, the State Department interprets the INA to mean that a child born abroad must be biologically related to a U.S. citizen parent, according to the departments website.

    Children born via gestational surrogacy or other forms of assisted reproductive technology (ART)children like Aiden and Ethan, who were born with the help of an anonymous egg donor and a gestational surrogateare considered by the State Department to be born out of wedlock, even if their parents are legally married, a status that erects higher hurdles for citizenship, including DNA tests to prove a biological relationship to a U.S. citizen parent with a sufficiently lengthy record of residency in the country.

    It was that policy that led to Andrew and Elads nightmare scenario: standing in the U.S. consulate in Toronto in January 2017, being told by a U.S. vice consul that without evidence of a biological relationship with Andrew, neither one of the twins would qualify for U.S. citizenship.

    To drop this bombshell that youre going to require a DNA test because youre only going going to grant citizenship to the child that is genetically connected to me, Andrew recalled, was very callouscold, robotic, and hurtful. Eventually, he said, he was bawling, crying my eyes out in the consulate as his childrens citizenship was thrown into question.

    This policy targets same-sex families, because, in most times, its clear that they had to use assisted reproductive technology, and they stick out, Elad said.

    Speaking to The Daily Beast in the offices of Immigration Equality, the nonprofit that advocates for LGBT people in the immigration system and is representing the Dvash-Bankses in court, Andrew and his husband Elad characterized the policy as rooted in the same state-sanctioned discrimination that forced them to move to Canada in the first place.


     

    Because of DOMA, binational couples got to know each other abroad and then couldnt sponsor the foreigner to come to the U.S., said Elad, an Israeli national, referring to the Defense of Marriage Act, a federal law that forbade the U.S. government from recognizing same-sex marriages. We were discriminated against when we wanted to live here, and we are continuing to be discriminated against today.

    The law, which barred U.S. citizens from sponsoring visas for foreign-born same-sex spouses, was the impetus behind Andrew and Elads decision to move to Canada shortly before getting married in 2010kickstarting a cycle of government exclusion that continues nearly a decade later.

    If DOMA never existed and they had been able to move to California, Andrew said, then we would have been living in L.A. instead of Toronto, enjoying the sunshine, and we probably would have found a surrogate there.

    We found ourselves in this situation because of the discrimination of DOMA.

    The governments discrimination against same-sex couples, Andrew and Elad said, far outlasted DOMA itself, which was struck down by the Supreme Court in 2013.


    Latest Discounts
  • Get a FREE Sample of This Revolutionary Superfood Today
  • What you absolutely must know about the one you're with. Life changing
  • Bolt your doors... lock your windows... and Watch This Mind-Blowing Video TODAY...
  • Learn Easy Couples Massage Techniques - Full Instructions and Videos
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Sex games that are used to quickly and easily increase the passion and intimacy of lovemaking.
  • Watch this video and GET READY for the next financial collapse, your family may depend on it.
  • Discover How Your Beliefs and Emotions Affect Your Ability To Achieve All Your Goals And Dreams.
  • Learn how to make wonderful smelling candles that put expensive candles sold in stores.
  • Over 8 Top Ranked Hypnosis Certification Courses And Programs
  • Add More Intimacy, Variety, Pleasure And Fun Into Your Sex Life With This Amazing Foreplay Game.
  • Download the latest official drivers for your PC fix driver problems and keep them updated.
  • The stunning secret of turning your wife on with the push of a button.
  • Delivers to you Akashic Records readings, Consciousness, Growth of Awareness etc...
  • Quickly cure your acid reflux and enjoy permanent freedom from heartburn
  • The Latest Boat Design Software Start building your dream Boat In 5 Mins
  • Make Money Online With This Pre-Loaded Wordpress eBook Store.
  • Dancing is a learned skill just like learning a new language With the right instructions.
  • This Affiliate System Will Have You Raking In Massive Commissions From Affiliate Marketing.
  • Clickbank Ads
     

    I wont forget that moment in the consulate that [the vice consul] told us, well, do you know who is genetically related to which one of you? And were like, what are you talking about? Elad said. You have our marriage license in front of youyou have the kids birth certificate with our names on them, why are you even asking us this? And then I got itshes only asking us that because were a same-sex couple.

    For Andrew and Elad, that suspicion was confirmed when they asked whether the same questions would have been raised if they had been an opposite-sex couple.

    What if Elad is the female foreign spouse and Im the American male spouse and Im infertile and we had to get a sperm donor who wasnt American? Andrew posed to the vice consul at the time. Our names are on the birth certificatewould you have asked?

    Her response was, its at my discretion who I decide to require a DNA test from.

    The fathers took their case to court, arguing successfully that the policy was implemented without any textual basis in the INA, and in contradiction to court precedents that have found using DNA testing to confer citizenship is a violation of federal law.

    But the State Departments appealand a flurry of similar cases, with more potentially on the waymeans that the case will continue to drag on before the Ninth Circuit hears the case.

    With oral arguments, its possible that those wont happen until a year from now, said Kristen Thompson, Immigration Equalitys communications director.

    As mop-topped toddlers Aiden and Ethan Dvash-Banksthe former a U.S. passport-holder since birth, the later only by the grace of a federal court rulingdoodled with markers and scratch paper, Andrew and Elad told The Daily Beast that they are confident that the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals will uphold the initial ruling that recognized Ethans birthright citizenship. But the time and energy required to see the case through, both fathers noted, isnt exactly easy to come by with twin toddlers in the house.

    When people hear about our story, they think that thats all we deal with every single day, and its like, theres so much more to raising 2-1/2-year-old twins! said Elad, whose sole goal in pursuing the suit is for the U.S. government to let us live our boring family life.

    Our children are our lifeas you can see, all we do is color and draw, Andrew added, as Ethan methodically applied marker caps to each of his digits. This situation is just so heavy on us, because as a parent, my first responsibility is to protect my child. Its just this extra burden.

    Original Article : HERE ; The Ultimate Survival Food: The Lost Ways

     


    RELATED PRODUCTS
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Watch this video and GET READY for the next financial collapse, your family may depend on it.
  • Learn Easy Couples Massage Techniques - Full Instructions and Videos
  • What you absolutely must know about the one you're with. Life changing
  • Sex games that are used to quickly and easily increase the passion and intimacy of lovemaking.
  • Get a FREE Sample of This Revolutionary Superfood Today
  • Bolt your doors... lock your windows... and Watch This Mind-Blowing Video TODAY...
  • This Affiliate System Will Have You Raking In Massive Commissions From Affiliate Marketing.
  • Dont Let Social Anxiety Control Your Life Any Longer. Start Living.
  • Protect Your Family with Parental Controls Download Internet Filter Now
  • The only program for the rabid American gun shooting market.
  • A certification course provides a certification as a hypnosist coach.
  • How To Rent To Own Your Dream Home Using The Lease Purchase Advantage
  • Discover The Ultimate Resource For Your Secret Lifestyle Vacation From True Lifestylers.
  • Learn How To Attract the Man of Your Dreams And Receive A Marriage Proposal In Few Months
  • Know how to eliminate bacterial vaginosis forever in 72 hour.
  • Clickbank Ads